From the Archives: Shock Absorbers

Dudley Hume was an engineer who worked closely with Sydney Allard during an important period in the company’s development. His work included suspension design and development, and he was directly involved in discussions around the divided-axle front suspension used on many Allards. His first-hand recollections therefore provide a particularly valuable insight into the engineering decisions, personalities and thinking behind the cars.


Shock absorbers, or dampers, to use the correct description can make the difference between a superb feeling motor car and one feeling like a bag of rusty nails.

At the time when Allards were being built manufacturers generally, particularly in the Midlands, regarded dampers as an unfortunate, er, necessity, to be obtained as cheaply as possible. Consequently the quality and resultant life of dampers was not very good, particularly the arm type dampers which cost more to produce and were not as durable as the telescopic type.

An almost common sight at one time was of certain models of the ‘nationalised’ motor industry proceeding in a gentle pitch and toss manner with no hope of stopping quickly or taking successful evasive action. In any case I am convinced that the Midlands ignored the handling aspect and concentrated on ride. Anyone who has driven such vehicles as Rover 105 or Humber Super Snipe will probably agree.

Fortunately in later years the importance of good dampers has been fully recognised and, of course, costs have gone up accordingly.

The telescopic dampers fitted to Allards, the so called ‘J’ type, cost the company fifteen shillings each (75p in todays parlance). These were made by Woodhead Monroe an offshoot of Jonas Woodhead, the spring manufacturers of Leeds. Monroe was an American manufacturer and Woodhead made them under Licence. Certainly at that time they were the best around having had many years experience of softly suspended coil spring cars and poor road surfaces in the States.

Some people in this country were still trying to promote friction dampers with adjustable characteristics but these efforts failed as their characteristics are the reverse of what is required to give good ride quality with predictable control of suspension movement at all stages of suspension deflection.

Leaf springs were also the enemy of good rider quality because, as they used to be made, they became clogged with mud and grit which could virtually seize them up, apart from the considerable friction between unground blades. Ground blades and full gaiters were priced out of the ordinary car market and in any case were not that durable.

Leaf spring design for rear suspension did improve, with fewer blades and plastic spacers to keep them apart to minimise the build up of mud and grit. The ultimate was the forged one piece spring tapered to give the correct characteristics which had no dry friction whatever, but by this time rear suspension had become as sophisticated as front suspension so one piece springs were only used on some commercial vehicles.

But of course all the time friction was being eliminated from suspension systems to improve ride quality the dampers were required to do more work in controlling the system.

It got to the stage a few years ago when the conventional telescopic damper was found to be preventing a further improvement in ride quality itself through the problems associated with the change over from one value characteristic to another. The firmer the setting the sharper the changeover.

The standard valve arrangement in telescopic dampers since the Monroe dampers of circa 1936 has been to have a ‘bleed’ valve and a ‘blow off’ valve for both bump and rebound. These four characteristics are all variable. Their precise orifice ratings for a particular model are determined by ‘ride testing’ using ‘ride test’ dampers which are readily opened up to change the valve sizes until a satisfactory ride is achieved.

Until recently this was always arrived at subjectively, the ride test engineers, having done their best, would submit the vehicles to senior management for their appraisal and opinion.

In the big companies several vehicles with slightly different settings would be submitted and the ‘committee’ would decide on the ‘favourite’.

In my days at Allard when the number of variations was more limited, i.e coarser steps, I would spend two or three days with the damper engineers until we had achieved what we mutually agreed was the best compromise and then Reg Canham or Sydney would take the car out and ‘confirm’ the settings. But although the best setting was shown on test to be fairly well defined it was not anything like as critical as in later years due to the inherent friction and high unsprung weight in the Allard system.

As mentioned above, there are basically four settings in a damper, the bump ‘bleed’, and dump ‘blow off’ and the same on rebound.

The bleed valve takes care of small, slow suspension movements and the blow off valve takes care of larger, quicker movements and it was the problems associated with achieving a smooth change over that brought about the gas filled damper. The gas under high pressure cushions the change over from one valve to another.

Generally speaking the resistance on the rebound characteristics is between two and three times as high as that on bump. This is to prevent the roadwheel returning too quickly to the road, the resultant shock would be worse than the original bump.

For some years now considerable efforts have been made to establish damper settings objectively for greater accuracy and quality. Many different types of test fixture have been built and developed in an effort to achieve this.

The main factors affecting ride quality are the bounce frequency of the road wheel and the unsprung weight of the suspension system at the wheel. Also the type of tyre and its pressure which of course is determined largely by the mass acting on a particular wheel.

Obviously ride quality is not the only criteria, vehicles nowadays, quite rightly, are required to have nimble, sure footed handling for safety reasons as well as being fun to drive.

This aspect involves the c of g of the vehicle and its effect dynamically on the mass distribution which in turn changes the conditions affecting the dampers so it will be appreciated that the situation gets very complicated from the mathematical viewpoint.

Computers have been working overtime on this subject, but I do not believe that anyone has yet achieved a set up which enables the damper settings for a particular vehicle to be accurately determined before the vehicle goes on the road.

Some test fixtures are arranged to hold the complete vehicle and hydraulic rams, programmed from actual road surface input, shake the vehicle about as though it were on the road. Instrumentation records the dynamic effect on the c of g and the resultant ‘G’ effect on different parts of the vehicle. Damper settings can then be changed until the ‘G’ effects are reduced to a minimum but I believe that there is still a lot of work to do on the handling aspect before the best ride and handling characteristics can be pre determined.

There has been mention in the technical press about the considerable amount of research that has been carried out on ‘active’ suspension for private cars but I noted recently a report that the programme had been stopped for lack of cash. That’s a pity but it is a very complex subject.

However, back to earth, I hope that shortly I will be able to produce a list of alternative and readily available dampers to suit the various Allard models.

Dudley Hume